The European Court of Human Rights (ECHR) agreed with the defense's arguments that the actions of NABU detectives violate European standards and human rights. The court's ruling also highlights the systematic disregard by the High Anti-Corruption Court (HACC) and its Appellate Chamber for the provisions of the Convention on Human Rights.
Boris Kaufman's lawyer, Igor Protsenko, confirmed the ECHR's decision, stating: "Unfortunately, the fight against corruption in Ukraine is turning into a spectacle. During searches, individuals who pose no threat and have no intention of fleeing are increasingly being detained. This creates a media 'image' but undermines the principles of justice when the HACC turns a blind eye to such violations. For these unlawful actions, the state will be compelled to pay compensation from the budget. Whether the Ministry of Justice will sue NABU detectives to recover funds is a question that requires public oversight."
Alexey Bebel, a lawyer for another suspect in the case, also reacted to the situation, welcoming the ECHR's decision: "The arbitrary detention of Kaufman and others went unchecked by the HACC judges, indicating the impunity of law enforcement. The fight against corruption must occur within the framework of the law, and law enforcement agencies must strictly adhere to it. It is time to abolish the unconstitutional provision that allows NABU detectives to detain individuals at their discretion. The law should protect human rights, not become a tool of pressure."
The ECHR's ruling has become an important precedent in the struggle for human rights in Ukraine and has resonated within the legal community and the public.